Current:Home > MarketsNCAA facing new antitrust suit on behalf of athletes seeking 'pay-for-play' and damages -MoneyStream
NCAA facing new antitrust suit on behalf of athletes seeking 'pay-for-play' and damages
View
Date:2025-04-14 04:47:58
Lawyers representing three college athletes filed a lawsuit against the NCAA and the Power Five conferences on Wednesday that challenges the association’s rules prohibiting athletes from being paid by their schools to play in their sports.
The case is being led by attorneys Steve Berman and Jeff Kessler, who have been — and remain — involved in several cases challenging various of the NCAA’s fundamental limits on compensation for athletes.
In this case, they are seeking an injunction that would end the association’s rules that prohibit schools from compensating athletes “for their athletic services.” They also seeking "substantial damages " for Bowl Subdivision football players and Division I men’s basketball and women’s basketball players at Power Five schools between Dec. 7, 2019, and whenever the date of judgment in this case occurs. This four-year reach-back for damages is permitted in antitrust cases.
The suit alleges that that the NCAA’s member schools “have passed a byzantine set of rules prohibiting the extremely talented young men and women who generate billions of dollars for the Division I sports business from receiving any compensation for their athletic services beyond an athletic scholarship and certain types of education-related benefits.
“These draconian, collusive rules prohibit what the NCAA refers to as ‘pay-for-play,’ but what anyone else would call market-value compensation. In college sports, only the athletes are treated as ‘amateurs.’ Everyone else involved enjoys the compensation that results from unrestrained competition for the athletes’ services.”
This becomes the latest in the type of antitrust lawsuit that the NCAA, its conferences and member schools are seeking to end through federal legislation that they also also want to use as vehicle to put national rules around college athletes’ activities to make money from their name, image and likeness (NIL).
The complaint was filed two days after NCAA President Charlie Baker sent a letter to NCAA membership proposing dramatic changes to the association's rules concern athlete compensation. The changes include creating a new competitive subdivision whose school would be required to “invest at least $30,000 per year into an enhanced educational trust fund for at least half of the institution’s eligible student-athletes.” In addition, Baker wrote that "rules should change for any Division I school, at their choice, to enter into name, image and likeness licensing opportunities with their student-athletes.”
Baker's proposal and his initial public comments expanding up upon them, Wednesday at the Sports Business Journal Intercollegiate Athletics Forum in Las Vegas, are both cited in the 66-page complaint. The suit then alleges that "any continued claim" by the NCAA and the conferences that amateurism is a justification for rules prohibiting schools from paying their athletes "is now factually bankrupt."
An NCAA spokesperson said Thursday evening that the association had comment at this time. But in what now seems like a prophetic exchange, Baker and Sports Business Journal's executive editor Abraham Madkour discussed the NCAA's legal issues and quest for Congressional intervention during Wednesday's event.
Baker: "Part of the reason we're talking to Congress is their ability to codify something, to say, 'Yes, the NCAA and its membership, based on what we know about what they're seeking to achieve here, should be able to actually do their job (in rules making).' I think it's an important element in this because otherwise, you just have everybody suing everybody all the time over everything."
Madkour: "Right. I mean, you could be dropped with another lawsuit tomorrow ..."
Baker: "I will be ..."
Baker went on to elaborate on why the NCAA wants a "little" antitrust exemption. With the constant threat of lawsuits, he said: "You can't operate an association that way. You just can't. And it's important for us to at least have enough ability to do something. Look, the conferences can't operate this way. … I get the fact that you got to figure out how to do this on a narrow enough basis so that it's not viewed as just a fundamental desire to restrict. But at the same time, I do worry that the next the next place people are going to go is academic eligibility."
Berman, of Seattle-based Hagens Berman Sobol Shapiro LLP, and Kessler, of Winston & Strawn LLP's New York office, oversaw the Alston antitrust case that ended in a unanimous Supreme Court ruling against the NCAA that lifted national limits on benefits for athletes that are related to education.
They are in the midst of another case that challenges the association’s remaining rules regarding athletes ability to make money from their NIL and seeks damages based on the share of television-rights money and the social media earnings it claims athletes would have received if the NCAA’s previous limits NIL compensation had not existed. A U.S. district judge has granted class-action status in the damages portion of that lawsuit, putting at least $4.2 billion at stake. The NCAA and the conferences are seeking review of that ruling by the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
Berman and Kessler also are pursuing a case on behalf of former Oklahoma State football player Chuba Hubbard and former Oregon and Auburn track and field athlete Keira McCarrell that seeks retroactive damages for thousands of college athletes based on the nearly $6,000-a-year academic-achievement payments that were allowed by a U.S. district court judge in March 2019 and upheld by the Supreme Court in the Alston case.
The new case was filed on behalf of Duke football player DeWayne Carter, Stanford women's soccer player Nya Harrison and TCU, and former Oregon, women's basketball player Sedona Prince. Prince also is among the named plaintiffs in the NIL-compensation case pending before the appeals court.
veryGood! (135)
Related
- Highlights from Trump’s interview with Time magazine
- The U.S. states where homeowners gained — and lost — equity in 2023
- UNLV shooting victims join growing number of lives lost to mass killings in US this year
- Texas teen struck, killed by semi after getting off school bus; driver charged with homicide
- 'Survivor' 47 finale, part one recap: 2 players were sent home. Who's left in the game?
- Why do doctors still use pagers?
- Nikki Haley's husband featured in campaign ad
- NBA getting what it wants from In-Season Tournament, including LeBron James in the final
- Are Instagram, Facebook and WhatsApp down? Meta says most issues resolved after outages
- Oprah Winfrey Shares Insight into Her Health and Fitness Transformation
Ranking
- North Carolina trustees approve Bill Belichick’s deal ahead of introductory news conference
- More than 70 million people face increased threats from sea level rise worldwide
- Deemed Sustainable by Seafood Industry Monitors, Harvested California Squid Has an Unmeasurable Energy Footprint
- Love Story Actor Ryan O’Neal Dead at 82
- Head of the Federal Aviation Administration to resign, allowing Trump to pick his successor
- Everyone knows Booker T adlibs for WWE's Trick Williams. But he also helped NXT star grow
- 'Leave The World Behind' director says Julia Roberts pulled off 'something insane'
- Teacher gifting etiquette: What is (and isn't) appropriate this holiday
Recommendation
McKinsey to pay $650 million after advising opioid maker on how to 'turbocharge' sales
The Excerpt podcast: VP Harris warns Israel it must follow international law in Gaza.
Russia puts prominent Russian-US journalist Masha Gessen on wanted list for criminal charges
Ashlyn Harris Steps Out With Sophia Bush at Art Basel Amid Ali Krieger Divorce
NFL Week 15 picks straight up and against spread: Bills, Lions put No. 1 seed hopes on line
AI creates, transforms and destroys... jobs
Lawmakers seek action against Elf Bar and other fruity e-cigarettes imported from China
Israeli military says it's surrounded the home of architect of the Oct. 7 Hamas attack